The fearsome flush isnt my auction. I posted my figures several weeks back (about 20), all of which sold off of ebay to mostly to private collectors, and the few that didnt I am goig to relist, I have many new ones as well.
Cloud City collectables is actually owned by Brians Toys now and so I am not sure they have anything to do with AFA any longer.
With regards to AFA figures, its really personal taste. High end collectors, meaning people who insure their collections, have them appraised etc, and have thousands and thousands of dollars worth of toys, dont just use AFA for the grading, even we dont agree sometimes, but the casing, authentication, and preservation techniques are really a major factor. For those who want more zeroes, that really only happens on really high end figures, items like fearsome flush as an example (auction in question) have been up on ebay for over a year now, re-listed over and over. For the casual collector, AFA probably isnt worth it, but the older a toy gets, the less chance there is of finding one in stellar shape, as the die hard collectors get them graded, casual folks often open them and store them loose, and any others just get held on to and often get damaged or lose value due to wear.
Anyways, like I said, its all personal taste. Fyi also, AFA has competitors now as well that do Action Figure grading…..