“OMG dey sold out and cut there haire!”

I think St Anger had a lot of cool stuff as well as some stuff that wasn't too great. The poor sound did overshadow anything that was good I think. I know they were going for the raw jamming sound but some moments of drums and Hetfield's off key wailing are a bit much at times. I think even I remember them looking back on it, it was something they felt they had to do at the time. Of all the things they've done on their own terms, I think it was the worst. S&M, Garage Inc and all the other “sellout” things people said they did yielded better results I think.
Most peoples problems with Load and Reload are usually they're not
really metal. As in it doesn't sound like their other stuff. I think it is however very much them. They took a little different direction and there were PLENTY of great and successful songs on those albums, in my opinion. There are admittedly a few songs I don't care for but if you give some of those songs a chance, they're the same Metallica quality, just a different hard rock/bluesy style/sound. Some people aren't into it so to each his own.
Those are my thoughts though. I probably shouldn't post too much more as I love Metallica and usually will defend to the death most everything they do and their right as musicians/human beings to do whatever the hell they want without people wanting to put limits or boundaries on what they think it's acceptable for them to do. Okay I'm ranting. :p
Oh yeah, on topic, looking forward to hearing it :-)