Rookie does speak *warning spoilers*


by ScottSommer

15 years, 7 months ago


I GOT THE VIDEO OF HIM SPEAKING.

Start the movie at 2:05 and go foreward and you will see him talk.

He says “Me too.”

Warning: UBER MAJOR SPOILERS!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdCi2U6-84o

by soulcreator

15 years, 7 months ago


um…that's Venkman. He even says “me neither, I mean” because he was correcting himself

by Trekkie2063

15 years, 7 months ago


the line IMMEDIATELY before that is the Rookie saying “Me too.”
Even look at the name tag of the character saying it. It's the Rookie

by soulcreator

15 years, 7 months ago


the camera does happen to move past the rookie at that time, but it's not actually him speaking. You can even check the subtitles.

“Me too! Me neither…I mean”

by JodisWelch

15 years, 7 months ago


Yes its Venkman that is saying that, not the Rookie. Same thing is said on the Wii version but the cutscene on the Wii version makes it more clear that Peter is saying it.

by Dakera

15 years, 7 months ago


Why would Venkman be saying that if he's first in line….


Also the rookie turns his head and his mouth moves a little when “Me too” is said.

by doctorvenkman1

15 years, 7 months ago


Dakera;149582
Why would Venkman be saying that if he's first in line….


Also the rookie turns his head and his mouth moves a little when “Me too” is said.

Just because the Rookie is first in the line doesn't mean he has to speak first.

His head moves, yes, but his mouth doesn't move in any way similar to the words “Me too”… its more just gritting his teeth.

I think this video makes it perfectly clear that this line is NOT spoken by the Rookie.

Let alone that Venkman wouldn't be saying “Me neither, I mean.” unless he was correcting something he had previously said, that being “Me too.”

It wouldn't make sense if the dialogue was…

Egon: I can't shut mine down.
Rookie: Me too.
Venkman: Me neither, I mean.

It only makes sense if its…

Egon: I can't shut mine down.
Venkman: Me too… Me neither, I mean.

The “I mean” shows us that Venkman must have said something before “Me neither”, and since the only thing before that is “Me too” its pretty easy to conclude that Venkman said that as well. Otherwise, he wouldn't be saying “I mean”.

by Dakera

15 years, 7 months ago


Doctor Venkman;149583
Just because the Rookie is first in the line doesn't mean he has to speak first.

His head moves, yes, but his mouth doesn't move in any way similar to the words “Me too”… its more just gritting his teeth.

I think this video makes it perfectly clear that this line is NOT spoken by the Rookie.

Let alone that Venkman wouldn't be saying “Me neither, I mean.” unless he was correcting something he had previously said, that being “Me too.”

It wouldn't make sense if the dialogue was…

Egon: I can't shut mine down.
Rookie: Me too.
Venkman: Me neither, I mean.

It only makes sense if its…

Egon: I can't shut mine down.
Venkman: Me too… Me neither, I mean.

The “I mean” shows us that Venkman must have said something before “Me neither”, and since the only thing before that is “Me too” its pretty easy to conclude that Venkman said that as well. Otherwise, he wouldn't be saying “I mean”.



Good arguement!

by ScottSommer

15 years, 7 months ago


Doctor Venkman;149583
Just because the Rookie is first in the line doesn't mean he has to speak first.

His head moves, yes, but his mouth doesn't move in any way similar to the words “Me too”… its more just gritting his teeth.

I think this video makes it perfectly clear that this line is NOT spoken by the Rookie.

Let alone that Venkman wouldn't be saying “Me neither, I mean.” unless he was correcting something he had previously said, that being “Me too.”

It wouldn't make sense if the dialogue was…

Egon: I can't shut mine down.
Rookie: Me too.
Venkman: Me neither, I mean.

It only makes sense if its…

Egon: I can't shut mine down.
Venkman: Me too… Me neither, I mean.

The “I mean” shows us that Venkman must have said something before “Me neither”, and since the only thing before that is “Me too” its pretty easy to conclude that Venkman said that as well. Otherwise, he wouldn't be saying “I mean”.

Look at this point I am uncertain, but I want to make several points that you all made.

There are some mistakes in this game where people are speaking and yet no mouths are moving. This scene included. If Venkman did say that line which now I am thinking he did because the voice sounds the same….his mouth does not move one inch. It stays in that grimace.

I have even had moments where Ray's mouth move yet no dialogue comes out. Like he was supposed to say something, but it was cut. Game mechanics have caused moments where dialogue can get cut despite it sounding like it is part of a whole.

I just want to clarify that just because someone's mouth moves or not proves they say something is wrong as mistakes can happen in animations. Even in movies it happens thanks to the editing process. How many times have you watched a movie where someone else's voice comes out of someone else's mouth?

by Dakera

15 years, 7 months ago


Scott Sommer;149630
Look at this point I am uncertain, but I want to make several points that you all made.

There are some mistakes in this game where people are speaking and yet no mouths are moving. This scene included. If Venkman did say that line which now I am thinking he did because the voice sounds the same….his mouth does not move one inch. It stays in that grimace.

I have even had moments where Ray's mouth move yet no dialogue comes out. Like he was supposed to say something, but it was cut. Game mechanics have caused moments where dialogue can get cut despite it sounding like it is part of a whole.

I just want to clarify that just because someone's mouth moves or not proves they say something is wrong as mistakes can happen in animations. Even in movies it happens thanks to the editing process. How many times have you watched a movie where someone else's voice comes out of someone else's mouth?



*Points at Godzilla movies*